top of page

Webinar
Is liberal democracy in decline?

irts telos.png

Is liberal democracy in Western Europe and the United States threatened primarily by populist and nationalist movements, or rather by established elites that are distancing themselves from the democratic will of the people? This was the central question at our webinar with the legendary British writer John O’Sullivan (former adviser to Margaret Thatcher) and Dr Eric Hendriks (Telos Institute, New York), organised in cooperation with the International Reagan Thatcher Society.

 

The webinar was prompted by the ongoing, heated public debate about the state of democracy in Western Europe and the United States, on the one hand, and Central and Eastern Europe, on the other. Both speakers argued that the greatest threat to liberal democracy does not necessarily come from populist or nationalist movements, but from elites that limit voters’ influence and transfer power to unelected institutions, judges, technocrats and international organisations.

​​

According to O’Sullivan and Hendriks, in Western Europe and North America a conception of democracy has emerged in which liberal values, human rights and institutional safeguards are becoming increasingly central. As a result, the original premise—that citizens shape the direction of government through elections—is receding into the background. They argued for restoring representative democracy, with national self-determination, parliamentary decision-making and voter influence, while retaining the safeguards of the rule of law.

The greatest threat comes from within

O’Sullivan acknowledged that democracy has enemies, including authoritarian states such as China and Russia, which are also increasingly working together. However, he challenged the idea that it is primarily radical right-wing movements that threaten democracy, arguing that this view is one-sided and misleading.

​​

According to O’Sullivan, the greatest threat to Western democracy comes from within. He pointed to the rise of a post-Western and post-democratic ideology which presents itself as an advanced understanding of democracy, but is uncomfortable with voters having an influence on political decision-making. As a result, power is shifting away from elected parliaments towards judges, international organisations and other unelected institutions. Even fully independent central banks can become problematic when they make political choices that should be the responsibility of elected representatives.

 

The Brexit referendum illustrated this, he argued. When the British public voted differently from what the established elite wanted, resistance emerged to implementing the result. This shows that some elites struggle to accept the democratic choice of citizens.

John_O'Sullivan_--.jpg
1732141662292.jpg

The historical background:

a changing conception

of democracy

Hendriks supported this analysis and placed it in a historical and philosophical context.

 

After the Second World War, Germany in particular had to protect its political system against extremist nationalism. This gave rise to the concept of militant democracy: institutions were equipped with safeguards to prevent anti-democratic movements from undermining the system from within. Particularly from the 1980s and 1990s onwards, the conviction also grew beyond Germany, in Western Europe and North America, that nationalism in itself poses a danger to democracy and freedom. Hendriks linked this, among other things, to the ideas of Jürgen Habermas, European integration and internationalisation.

 

In this way, the meaning of democracy changed among societal elites. Alongside parliament and the will of the people, the rule of law, human rights, minority rights and liberal freedoms came to feature ever more prominently within a single, integrated concept of democracy. According to Hendriks, an essential distinction was lost in the process: liberal principles and the principles of the rule of law should serve as safeguards and checks and balances within a democracy, not replace democratic decision-making.

The difference between Western and Eastern Europe

Because countries such as Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic and Slovakia experienced both National Socialist and communist totalitarianism, Hendriks argued that their relationship with national sovereignty differs from the prevailing view in Western Europe. For these countries, national independence meant resistance to totalitarian domination. The slogan ‘Wir sind das Volk’ (‘We are the people’), heard during the East German protests of 1989, expressed the same conviction: the people must be able to decide their own political future.

 

After the fall of communism, Eastern Europeans expected to become part of a democratic Europe as free nations. According to Hendriks, they subsequently found

that their national identity and their aspiration to self-determination were increasingly viewed with suspicion.

 

In this context, Hendriks emphasised that nationalism is not automatically wrong. Nationalism does indeed become dangerous when it involves notions of superiority and exclusion, but a moderate national patriotism can foster a sense of belonging and provide resistance to totalitarianism.

pexels-koprivakart-5771192.jpg
pexels-johndetochka-15871440.jpg

The European Union and populism

Both speakers saw the European Union as an example of the shift from democratic to technocratic governance. As a result of European integration, national sovereignty has increasingly given way to supranational decision-making. Hendriks argued that supporters of this process see the European Commission not only as a technocratic institution, but also as a representative of universal democratic values. This creates a paradox: national movements are criticised for emphasising their own interests and identity, while the EU itself is simultaneously developing a shared, ‘neo-nationalist’ political identity.

 

According to both speakers, parties such as Germany’s AfD should therefore not be labelled anti-democratic solely on account of their nationalist positions. Their ideas should be assessed on their substance and by the same democratic standards as those of other parties. O’Sullivan also pointed out that established parties often fail to address voters’ concerns adequately, for example over immigration. When these concerns are ignored, populist movements gain ground. Excluding and stigmatising such parties can further increase polarisation.

 

O’Sullivan stated that since 2014 American politics has responded more quickly than European politics to voters’ discontent and alienation. In his view, Trump succeeded in reaching groups who felt ignored, particularly on immigration and overseas military involvement. O’Sullivan did, however, express reservations about Trump’s unpredictable leadership style and protectionist trade policy. He expected elements of Trumpism, such as a more nationally oriented foreign policy, to remain influential beyond Trump.

Conclusion

The speakers maintained that liberal democracy must be protected not only against authoritarian regimes and extremist movements, but also against the ever-greater restriction of the popular will by unelected elites and institutions. O’Sullivan and Hendriks argued for a democracy in which citizens have genuine influence on the political direction, national self-determination is respected, and political differences can be discussed openly.

 

Their warning: a democracy undermines itself when, under the pretext of protecting itself, it leaves ever less room for the choices of its citizens. The challenge is to maintain a balance between democratic decision-making, the protection afforded by the rule of law, individual freedoms, and national cohesion.

pexels-dhenry-6436372.jpg
Tocqueville_Network_Logo_1_edited_edited_edited.png

Stichting Tocqueville Netwerk

Stichting Tocqueville Netwerk is the legal entity behind the Tocqueville Network. The Tocqueville Network operates under this name and uses www.tocqueville.nl as its official and primary website.

Contact

​info@tocqueville.nl

​

Follow us on LinkedIn!

​

​

​

​

Kruitmolen 48

1398 HA Muiden

The Netherlands


Chamber of Commerce (KvK): 97843318

RSIN: 868256493​

  • LinkedIn

​

© 2025 by Tocqueville Netwerk

 

bottom of page